Meetings
 
 
Print
AGENDA ITEM REPORT

Title: Report on Legislation to Develop Law Enforcement Training to Address the Needs of Persons with Developmental and Intellectual Disabilities
REPORT PROFILE
MEETING DATE
2/20/2014
BUREAU SUBMITTING THIS REPORT
Executive Office
RESEARCHED BY (PRINT NAME)
Charles Evans
REVIEWED BY (PRINT NAME)
Alan Deal
REPORT DATE
02/03/2014
APPROVED BY
Robert A. Stresak
DATE APPROVED
02/05/2014
PURPOSE
Decision Requested
FINANCIAL IMPACT
No

ISSUE, BACKGROUND, ANALYSIS, & RECOMMENDATION
ISSUE:
Should the Commission take a position on SB 663 (Lara) involving the updating of law enforcement training concerning crimes involving persons with developmental disabilities, intellectual disabilities, cognitive impairments and communication impairments?
BACKGROUND:
Senate Bill (SB) 663 (Lara) replicates many of the provisions of existing law regarding investigating and reporting of crimes related to persons with developmental and intellectual disabilities.

On October 9, 2013, Assembly Bill (AB) 602 (Yamada) added Section 13515.30 (a) to the Penal Code and amended sections of the Welfare and Institutions Code relating to mentally and developmentally disabled persons.  The statute requires POST to establish and keep updated a continuing education training course relating to law enforcement interaction with mentally disabled and developmentally disabled persons living within a state mental hospital or state developmental center.  It further specifies that the course be developed by the Commission in consultation with various entities that have expertise in the area of mental illness and developmental disability, including appropriate representatives of consumer and family advocate groups.  It also requires POST to examine existing courses related to mentally and developmentally disabled persons.  Finally, it requires that POST make the course available to all law enforcement agencies in California and requires law enforcement agencies with jurisdiction over state hospitals and state developmental centers to complete the course as part of the agency’s officer training program.  Completion of the course is on the POST development schedule for 2014. 

SB 663 was introduced by Senator Lara in January 2014. The provisions of this bill, similar to AB 602, also require the development of training related to crimes involving persons with developmental and intellectual disabilities. The individuals described in SB 602 have unique needs, characteristics, barriers and challenges that require services by California’s peace officers, specifically trained to respond to their needs. 

According to the author: “Approximately 5% of the nation's population has a developmental disability. Tragically, this population is much more likely to face abuse, especially sexual assault than others without disabilities. These crimes go unreported and unprosecuted. Crime victims with developmental disabilities often require assistance or accommodations during a police investigation. Despite the number of Californians living with developmental disabilities, law enforcement receives little to no training on serving these kinds of victims. As a result many perpetrators are never held accountable for their crimes and victims face repeated abuse. Senate Bill 663 will direct POST to develop and make available a training module to educate law enforcement on the unique challenges they will face when investigating crimes against people with developmental disabilities. The training will equip officers to properly investigate crimes against those with developmental disabilities and ensure victims get the justice they deserve.”

Staff has worked closely with the author of SB 663, and provided considerable resources and training material previously developed and updated by POST specifically addressing the author's concerns.  The author continues to move the bill but has accepted amendments suggested by staff.
ANALYSIS:

SB 663 would:

  • Require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, upon the next regularly scheduled review of a training module relating to persons with disabilities, to create and make available a training course regarding the investigation of crimes against or involving individuals with developmental disabilities, intellectual disabilities, cognitive impairments, and communication impairments, as specified.
  • Require the continuing education training course relating to law enforcement interaction with mentally disabled and developmentally disabled persons living within a state mental hospital or state developmental center to be integrated and coordinated with the training course developed pursuant to the bill provision.
  • Express the intent of the Legislature in enacting the provision developing the new course, to encourage the establishment of crime investigation units in law enforcement agencies throughout the state, specializing in investigating crimes against or involving individuals with developmental disabilities, intellectual disabilities, cognitive impairments, and communication impairments, including, but not limited to, investigating crimes involving the sexual exploitation and sexual abuse of developmentally disabled children and adults.

SB 663 imposes a one-time cost in excess of $100,000 (funded through the Peace Officers' Training Fund) to develop the required curriculum.  The required update of the course at some future date, the date of which to be determined by staff, would normally be considered a usual operating expense.  In previous years, the practice of the Commission has been to accept costs related to legislative mandates as absorbable to POST.  The Commission may wish to assess this practice in determining a position to take on this bill. 

The Commission is aware that POST has had to take action to reduce its operating costs.  The approach recommended by staff was approved by the Commission at its October 2013 meeting.  The anticipated reduction was approved by the Department of Finance and is reflected in the Governor's Budget which shows a $6.6 million expenditure reduction in POST's budget for Fiscal Year 2014-15.  This is driven by declining revenue to the Peace Officers' Training Fund.  This initiation of the cost-savings measures to conserve revenue will directly impact agencies as POST reduces training reimbursements, services and resources provided to law enforcement. 

Although not a Commission issue, SB 663 effectively amends Penal Code section 13515.30 by incorporating the new training to be developed by POST (by adding Penal Code section 13519.06), which will increase the existing unfunded legislative mandate for local agencies affected by the provision of the statute.

Senate Bill 663 expresses legislative intent for law enforcement agencies to develop specialized investigative units to address the needs of individuals described in the bill.  This may result in significant future costs to the General Fund to the extent state law enforcement agencies (e.g., CHP and DOJ,) establish specialized crime investigation units as described in the bill, however, it avoids creating a specific unfunded legislative mandate for local agencies that create such specialized investigative units. 

Although the author has agreed to make changes to SB 663 suggested by staff, there are sufficient issues remaining that should be examined by the Commission in making the decision to take a position on the bill.  For this reason, staff does not offer the Commission an opinion for a position. 

RECOMMENDATION:
Should the Commission take a position on SB 663 (Lara) involving the updating of law enforcement training concerning crimes involving persons with developmental disabilities, intellectual disabilities, cognitive impairments and communication impairments?
 
ATTACHMENT(S):
Name: Type:
No Attachments Available